In the past year it’s been necessary for me to work with multiple departments in four (4) Local Authorities; three in California and one in Massachusetts.
The relevance here is the range of skills, support and service I experienced.
One of the organizations was all you could hope for:
Courteous
Professional
Organized
Efficient
Yet the (3) others ranged from quite bad to deliberately obstructive on many fronts. Normally one would expect these groups to demonstrate the characteristics mentioned above and also function to:
Enforce Laws, Rules and Procedures
Clarify Requirements
Guide and Educate Customers
Facilitate Results
And, so on.
But the most prevalent characteristics I found in three of these groups were:
Obstructionism
Threatening Behavior
Severe Inconsistency
Absent Procedure
Cynicism
And, more.
All those involved are Civil Servants; seemly here an oxymoron by any measure. But, why is their behavior so adrift?
Generally when an individual is severely off-base in the workplace there is Corrective Action. If they are not subsequently fixed we move them on in some manner.
In the instances described there are multiple problematic factors in play. Customers are generally fearful of reporting poor service as retribution can/does follow. Also, those people reported often receive tacit support for their actions from immediate supervisors. Sadly, this is all part of what I witnessed.
It leaves one to ponder how an organization can both become and remain so pervasively dysfunctional.
So much for this illustrative Tale of Woe. Now let’s consider the implications.
In my view many of the problems are generically caused by one factor: Poor Supervision.
In all cases I noticed there was a difficult employee tolerated and unchecked by their immediate boss. It seems that this affect had crept over many years to multiple levels in the management chain, leaving whole departments rotten to the top. True, there are other ways such systematic bad behavior can emerge, exist and then grow.
As we have seen many times; if things are right at the top, good things flow downwards. Unfortunately the corollary and opposite are equally true.
When an employee is out of line, it’s his/her boss’s job to correct the problem. Failure to address means that boss then becomes the problem.
Regardless the seniority or position of the person involved, a supervisor must act.
When clients don’t report service and support issues it often means they are especially upset. The rule of thumb: one unhappy customer will tell twenty others of their mistreatment. Certainly, this is always bad for business.
As a leader, if you don’t get out and check what’s going on with your subordinates work, you will not have a true or complete picture. Better to tag along on visits, or perhaps have informal customer meetings and test those waters.
After all, if you don’t confirm what’s real and then correct issues, you become the problem.
Have you recently checked downstream on customers’ satisfaction with your employees and service? It would be wise to diplomatically and consistently insert yourself in the process to secure an accurate, first-hand reading.
Ian R. Mackintosh is the author of Empower Your Inner Manager Twitter @ianrmackintosh